Best Substitute for Shiitake Mushroom

Have you ever been in the middle of making a delicious recipe, only to realize that you don’t have any shiitake mushrooms on hand? Luckily, plenty of substitutes for shiitake mushrooms can make just as tasty a dish. Read on for a suitable substitute for shiitake mushrooms.

What are Shiitake Mushrooms?

Shiitake mushrooms are edible mushrooms typically found in East Asian cuisines.

They have a savory, delicious flavor and a meaty, firm texture, making them the perfect addition to various dishes.

Shiitake mushrooms have been part of Asian cooking for centuries, with ancient recipes showing that it was used as a meat substitute due to their high nutritional content and umami flavor.

Over the centuries, they have become a staple in many cuisines across Asia, including Chinese, Japanese, Thai, Korean, and Vietnamese dishes.

Not only do they add a robust flavor to food, but they can also be incredibly beneficial to our health.

They are versatile as there are several ways to cook shiitake mushrooms, including sauteing, baking, frying, and making the most delicious soups and brown sauces.

Shiitake mushrooms contain essential vitamins and minerals such as Vitamin B2, copper, zinc, and iron.

They also contain lentinan, believed to possess anti-cancer properties and have been studied for its potential therapeutic benefits.

Read why Shiitake mushrooms are healthy here.

Best Substitutes for Shiitake Mushrooms

Here we look at the best shiitake mushroom substitutes. You can replace shiitake mushrooms with other mushroom varieties with a similar taste profile and texture and impart the all-important umami flavor to your dishes.

Porcini Mushrooms

Porcini mushrooms are a great shiitake mushroom substitute for anyone looking for a flavorful addition to their meal.

They have a rich, earthy flavor that is often likened to that of nuts and can provide plenty of umami-filled satisfaction.

Because porcini mushrooms are popular, they are expensive but slightly more affordable than shiitake mushrooms.

You also don’t need to worry about dehydrating them before use; they can be cooked fresh, adding even more convenience than the mushroom they are substituting.

The only thing they lack when compared to shiitake mushrooms is the latter’s greater intensity of aroma and flavor. Still, porcinis make up for this with their superior texture that works especially well when cooked in recipes such as risotto and sauces.

Related: 9 Creative Substitutes for Asparagus

Dried Shiitake Mushroom

Dried shiitake mushrooms are a great alternative to fresh shiitake mushrooms, providing an easy and convenient way to incorporate this flavor-packed ingredient into any recipe.

Shiitakes lose much of their water content during the drying process, significantly increasing their flavor intensity.

The flavor intensification will bring a savory umami richness to your dishes without adding extra fat or calories.

Additionally, dried shiitake mushrooms keep for months when stored in an air-tight container, making them an easy pantry staple you can always turn to.

This is especially useful when fresh shiitake mushrooms are unavailable or out of season as you can easily substitute them in recipes without sacrificing quality or flavor.

Portobello Mushrooms

Portobello mushrooms are an excellent alternative to shiitake mushrooms, as they provide a similar meaty texture and depth of flavor. 

Unlike shiitake mushrooms, which must be reconstituted before use and sometimes have a slight bitterness, portobellos are ready-to-eat right out of the package. 

Additionally, their large size makes them ideal for stuffing, grilling, or slicing into soups or sauces. Their mild flavor can be easily enhanced with other ingredients or seasonings to create delicious dishes without the preparation time associated with shiitake mushrooms. All in all, portobello mushrooms can be an easy and flavorful substitute for shiitake mushrooms in most recipes.

Related: 7 Burrata Cheese Substitutes

Cremini Mushrooms

Cremini mushrooms are a great substitute for shiitake mushrooms in any dish. Sometimes referred to as crimini mushrooms, they are much lower in cost than traditional shiitake, and their flavor and texture are very similar.

Creminis have a meatier texture with an earthy, rich umami taste that provides a deliciously savory flavor to whatever dish you add them to. Additionally, they can be a healthy alternative to higher-fat meats such as beef or pork in many dishes, adding extra nutrition with similar results.

So if you’re looking for a not-so-expensive alternative to shiitakes with similar flavors and textures, Cremini mushrooms make an ideal choice.

Related: Best Substitutes for Galangal

Oyster Mushrooms

Oyster mushrooms are a great substitute for shiitake mushrooms due to their fragrant, woody flavor and versatile textures.

They’re also quicker and easier to work with than shiitakes; no soaking is necessary, and the small pieces cook much faster.

Nutritionally, oyster mushrooms pack a good amount of fiber, protein, and vitamins such as B6, C, and D.

Lastly, oyster mushrooms are more affordable than shiitake mushrooms, making them suitable for all budgets.

Enoki Mushrooms

Enoki mushrooms make an excellent substitution for shiitake mushrooms in numerous recipes.

They provide a similar umami flavor to shiitakes but with a lighter and more delicate taste.

Also, enoki mushrooms are much easier to clean and prepare before adding them to dishes or salads since they grow in bunches.

To top it off, enoki mushrooms usually cost less than shiitakes. They have many beneficial health attributes, such as high levels of antioxidants, active enzymes, and vitamins C, D, and B-12, which can help lower cholesterol.

King Oyster Mushrooms

King oyster mushrooms are an excellent substitute for shiitakes in any recipe.

They look similar and share many of the same textures and flavors, making them extremely versatile and suitable for many dishes and cuisines.

King oyster mushrooms are particularly useful for those looking for a vegan-friendly shiitake substitute due to their meaty texture, making them great for stir-fries and fried dishes.

Additionally, king oysters contain more nutrients than shiitake mushrooms, including calcium, magnesium, phosphorus, zinc, folates, and B vitamins.

Lobster Mushrooms

Lobster mushrooms make excellent shiitake mushroom substitutes for vegetarian dishes as they provide a meaty and chewy texture to dishes while still providing plenty of umami flavor.

In contrast with shiitakes, lobster mushrooms grow in clusters, and the individual lobsters average double the size of their shiitake counterparts.

This makes them excellent candidates for everything from salad to soup to even pasta dishes; cut each mushroom into halves or quarters, and they’ll add an instantly earthy flavor no matter which dish you’re making!

Maitake Mushrooms

Maitake mushrooms are an exceptional substitute for shiitake mushrooms due to their similar yet subtle flavor profile and adaptability in dishes. 

These mushrooms have the same mild umami taste and a meaty texture comparable to shiitakes.

In addition, maitakes have a relatively large cap that can be easily sliced or diced for use in stir-fries and soups, making them highly versatile as an ingredient.

Best of all, they have various health benefits, such as boosting immunity and providing antibacterial properties – making them an ideal choice over shiitakes in many contexts.

Summary – Best Substitutes for Shiitake Mushrooms

As well as the main shiitake mushroom substitutes, such as porcini mushrooms and dried shiitake mushrooms, you can consider different mushrooms, such as other dark brown mushrooms or white button mushrooms. Dried mushrooms are also a good alternative if you are looking for a concentrated flavor. 

Related: Dark Soy Sauce Substitutes